Attention all dessert lovers: Costco’s new sundae is here, and it’s a game-changer for anyone who’s ever craved a Girl Scout Cookie Thin Mint in ice cream form. But here’s where it gets controversial—while I’ve always been a loyal fan of Costco’s pepperoni pizza, this minty masterpiece might just steal the spotlight. Launched just in time for St. Patrick’s Day and Girl Scout Cookie season, the Double Chocolate Mint Sundae is a limited-time treat you won’t want to miss. Here’s why it’s worth the hype—and why it might just spark a debate among dessert enthusiasts.
What’s All the Fuss About?
Costco rolled out its Double Chocolate Mint Sundae in mid-to-late February, though some lucky locations got it earlier, leaving the rest of us drooling over social media posts. This sundae features mint soft serve—a bold replacement for the usual chocolate in Costco’s two-flavor machines. And this is the part most people miss—while there’s no mint-chocolate swirl, you can still get a mint-vanilla swirl if you’re not fully committed to the minty madness. The sundae is layered with chocolate sauce and crunchy, chocolatey cookie crumbles, earning its ‘double chocolate’ title. Priced at $2.99, it’s 50 cents more than the classic chocolate or strawberry sundaes, but trust me, it’s worth every penny. Just be quick—this festive treat won’t stick around forever.
Is It Worth the Hype?
In one word: absolutely. If you’re a Thin Mint fan, this sundae is like a dream come true. The cookie crumbles aren’t Oreos—they’re crunchier and more chocolatey, reminiscent of a Thin Mint without the shell. Costco doesn’t skimp on these crumbs either; there’s a generous layer at the bottom and on top. My only gripe? I could’ve used more chocolate sauce, especially in the middle where the mint ice cream dominated. But hey, that might just depend on who’s behind the counter. The mint flavor leans more Shamrock Shake than Thin Mint, but that’s not a bad thing—it’s a refreshing balance that keeps the sundae from being overly sweet. My partner and I devoured the entire large cup without a hint of sugar overload, and we’re already planning our next trip.
But Wait, There’s More Minty Goodness Out There
If you miss out on Costco’s sundae, don’t worry—mint chocolate season is in full swing, and other fast-food chains are stepping up their game. Here are some worthy alternatives:
- McDonald’s Shamrock Shake: A classic since 1967, this mild mint-and-vanilla blend even wins over mint skeptics.
- Wendy’s Girl Scout Thin Mints Frosty: Back by popular demand, this treat lets you choose between chocolate or vanilla Frosty, mixed with a minty cookie crumble sauce.
- Dairy Queen Mint Oreo Blizzard: A mint chocolate masterpiece with Oreo pieces and mint sauce swirled into vanilla soft serve.
Now, Here’s the Real Question
Is Costco’s Double Chocolate Mint Sundae the ultimate mint chocolate dessert, or do you think other options take the crown? And while we’re at it, is mint chocolate even deserving of its seasonal spotlight, or is it overhyped? Let’s settle this in the comments—have you tried Costco’s new sundae? What’s your take on the mint chocolate craze? Share your thoughts, and let’s spark a friendly (but fierce) debate!
